November 11, 2003. Dream Theater released “Train of Thought”, and this time they weren’t in the mood to play it safe. After years of long progressive pieces and changing musical directions, the band wanted something heavier, darker and more direct.
The idea came from playing live. Fans were reacting strongly to the heavier songs, and Dream Theater decided to follow that energy. They took inspiration from Metallica and Black Sabbath and wrote the entire album in just three weeks.
The result? Seven tracks, almost 70 minutes of music, thick riffs, complex rhythms and plenty of room for the musicians to show what they can do. This is often called the heaviest Dream Theater album, and it’s easy to understand why.
Three Weeks, No Time to Mess Around
The lineup was James LaBrie on vocals, John Petrucci on guitar and backing vocals, Jordan Rudess on keyboards, John Myung on bass and Mike Portnoy on drums and backing vocals.
After touring with Queensrÿche, the band wanted to capture a raw, “balls to the wall” sound. They didn’t spend ages trying to make everything perfect. They wanted energy, aggression and heavy riffs.
Honestly, “Train of Thought” just hits differently compared to their older prog stuff. The keyboards take a back seat this time around, letting the thick guitar riffs and hard hitting grooves completely dominate the mix.
Not everyone loved the change. Some fans and critics praised the technical playing and heavier direction, while others weren’t so impressed with the lyrics or felt the keyboards didn’t get enough attention. But the album certainly made people talk.
“As I Am” A Guitarist Who Had Enough
The opening track and lead single, “As I Am”, gets straight to the point. That dark, heavy riff sets the mood, and John Petrucci brings a fiery guitar solo.
There’s a pretty wild story behind the lyrics, too. Word has it that during a joint tour, Petrucci had a deeply frustrating backstage encounter with Queensrÿche guitarist Mike Stone, who actually tried to give the Dream Theater virtuoso unwanted guitar lessons.
Petrucci turned that experience into “As I Am”. Sometimes the best response is to pick up your guitar and write a heavy song about it.
There’s another nice detail connecting the album to its predecessor. The opening chord of “As I Am” picks up the final sound effect from “Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence”. A little connection between the two records before the new album even gets going.
Seven Tracks, Almost 70 Minutes
There are only seven songs on “Train of Thought”, but don’t expect a short ride. The album runs for 69 minutes and 21 seconds, with several tracks stretching well beyond ten minutes.
Here are some of the highlights:
- “This Dying Soul” – An 11-minute heavy track connected to Mike Portnoy’s ongoing “Twelve-Step Suite”, which follows his battle and recovery from alcoholism.
- “Endless Sacrifice” – Another 11-minute journey, with aggressive verses and melodic progressive sections. Its lyrics deal with the life of a musician constantly away on tour.
- “Honor Thy Father” – Fast, aggressive and full of heavy rhythms. The track also includes uncredited movie samples from “Magnolia” and “The Royal Tenenbaums”.
- “Vacant” – A short, melancholic break from the heavier material. James LaBrie wrote it about his daughter’s brief medical coma and Eugene Friesen adds a beautiful cello performance.
- “Stream of Consciousness” – The album central instrumental piece and the longest instrumental track on any Dream Theater studio album. No vocals needed here, the musicians do all the talking.
- “In the Name of God” – A 14-minute closing track and one of the biggest fan favorites on the album. Heavy, complex and full of details that are easy to miss on the first listen.
The Hidden Message in “In the Name of God”
Dream Theater are known for hiding little details in their music and this track has a particularly funny one.
Between 5:51 and 6:07, there’s a Morse code message buried in the music. When translated, it spells out Mike Portnoy’s famous catchphrase: “eat my ass and balls”.
Not exactly what you expect to discover in the middle of a 14-minute progressive metal epic!
And there’s one more strange detail. The final note of the entire album, heard at 14:06 in “In the Name of God”, was played by Jordan Rudess using his nose. This was captured in the “Making of Train of Thought” documentary.
That’s one way to finish an album.
A Heavy Album With a Different Kind of Emotion
For all the aggression on “Train of Thought”, the band also made room for something much quieter. “Vacant” stands out because it doesn’t try to compete with the heavy tracks. Its piano, cello and emotional background give the album a completely different feeling.
That contrast makes the heavier moments hit even harder when the music kicks back in.
“Train of Thought” may not be everyone’s favorite Dream Theater record, but it showed another side of the band. They could slow down, build huge progressive arrangements and explore complicated musical ideas, but they could also turn up the heaviness and let the riffs take over.
What’s your favorite track from “Train of Thought”? Are you more into the heavy side of “As I Am” and “This Dying Soul”, or the long progressive journeys like “Stream of Consciousness” and “In the Name of God”?
By
By
By
