• Home
  • Album Battle
  • Album Battle: Anvil – “Metal on Metal” vs. “Forged in Fire”
Album Battle: Anvil - “Metal on Metal” vs. “Forged in Fire”

Album Battle: Anvil – “Metal on Metal” vs. “Forged in Fire”

Anvil never needed fancy tricks to make heavy metal. Give them a guitar, a loud bass, drums and a good riff and they’re ready to go.

In the early ’80s, the Canadian band gave us two albums that didn’t just deserve a place in any classic metal collection, they directly inspired the emerging “Big Four” of thrash (Metallica, Slayer, Megadeth and Anthrax) with their speed and aggressive riffing: “Metal on Metal” (1982) and “Forged in Fire” (1983).

Released just a year apart, these records have plenty in common, but each has its own character. “Metal on Metal” has that raw, dirty energy, while “Forged in Fire” pushes things towards faster riffs and a harder attack.

So, which one would you put on when you want some proper old-school metal?

Anvil - “Metal on Metal” VS “Forged in Fire”

View Results

Loading ...

“Metal on Metal” (1982)

Anvil’s second album came out in 1982, and the title says pretty much everything you need to know. “Metal on Metal” is packed with heavy riffs, aggressive rhythms and that no-nonsense attitude that made early ’80s metal so exciting.

The lineup featured Steve “Lips” Kudlow on vocals and guitar, Dave Allison on rhythm guitar, Ian Dickson on bass and Robb Reiner on drums. Chris Tsangarides handled production and engineering.

The title track is the obvious anthem. It’s the kind of song that makes you want to turn the volume all the way up. It even appeared in a 2010 episode of The Simpsons. Not bad for a metal song!

But don’t stop there. “March of the Crabs” is a fast instrumental that later found its way onto the soundtrack of the video game Brütal Legend, along with “Tag Team”. “Mothra” and “Jackhammer” bring more heavy riffing, while “Stop Me” stands out because Dave Allison takes over lead vocals.

There’s also “666”, which appeared on the soundtrack of the 2017 film adaptation of Stephen King’s It.

The album was praised for its raw energy and guitar work and its cover art by Dean Motter even earned Anvil a 1983 Juno Award for Best Album Graphics.

This is Anvil with nothing to prove and plenty of metal to deliver.

“Forged in Fire” (1983)

Just one year later, Anvil returned with their third studio album, “Forged in Fire”. The title track opens the record with a heavy metal punch and the album doesn’t take long to get moving.

The lineup remained the same, with Steve “Lips” Kudlow, Dave Allison, Ian Dickson and Robb Reiner. Chris Tsangarides was back behind the production and engineering, with the album recorded at Phase One Studios in Toronto.

This time, there’s a stronger focus on speed and aggressive playing. Robb Reiner’s double-bass drumming adds plenty of power and the guitars keep things moving.

“Forged in Fire” is the big opening statement, but there’s more to enjoy. “Shadow Zone” and “Motormount” bring faster cuts, while “Free as the Wind” gives the album one of its longer standout tracks. “Make It Up to You” was released as the album’s single and “Winged Assassins” also deserves a mention.

The title track later received covers from bands including Benediction and Sinister Realm.

“Forged in Fire” is often seen as a cult classic and it’s easy to hear why. It has that old-school heavy metal sound, but there’s also a faster edge that points towards the direction metal would take in the years ahead.

The Battle: Which Anvil Album Wins?

Now this is a battle for the old-school metal fans.

“Metal on Metal” has the raw energy, the signature title track and songs that helped make Anvil’s name. “Forged in Fire” comes with faster riffs, aggressive drumming and a heavier push towards the speed metal sound.

Both albums have their fans, and neither one needs to hide behind the other. But we need to pick a winner!

If you could keep only one Anvil album, would it be “Metal on Metal” or “Forged in Fire”?

Releated Posts

Today in Metal History – 22nd November

Today in Metal History – 22nd November November 22nd 1985 Dokken – “Under Lock And Key” “Under Lock…

ByByDark Luna Nov 22, 2026

Pick or Pass: Is Sepultura’s “Roots” a Metal Masterpiece or a Step Too Far?

Some albums change a band’s sound. Others divide its fanbase for decades. Sepultura’s “Roots” did both. Released in…

ByByDark Luna Nov 21, 2026

Kerry King: How Much Slayer Is Too Much Slayer?

Kerry King doesn’t need an introduction. For more than four decades, he is one of the driving forces…

ByByDark Luna Nov 21, 2026

Today in Metal History – 21st November

Today in Metal History – 21st November November 21st 1981 Loudness – “The Birthday Eve” “The Birthday Eve”…

ByByDark Luna Nov 21, 2026

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *