Some albums change a band’s sound. Others divide its fanbase for decades.
Sepultura’s “Roots” did both.
Released in February 1996 and produced by Ross Robinson, best known for his work with Korn and Slipknot. The album took the band in a very different direction from the thrash metal attack of “Beneath the Remains” and “Arise”. The guitars became heavier, lower-tuned and groovier, the rhythms took centre stage, and Brazilian musical influences became a huge part of the sound.
It was a bold move and commercially, it paid off, pushing “Roots” to No. 27 on the US Billboard 200, the highest chart peak of Sepultura’s career.
But did it work musically? And it also marked the end of an era, serving as the final studio album to feature founding frontman Max Cavalera before his departure later that year.
Let’s look at the good, the bad and the reasons metal fans still argue about this album.
The Good: Sepultura Found Their Own Sound
“Roots” doesn’t sound like a band trying to repeat its past. It sounds like Sepultura pushing their music somewhere new.
The title track, “Roots Bloody Roots”, remains one of their most recognisable songs. Its crushing groove and memorable riff make it hard to forget. “Attitude” brings another dose of aggression, while “Ratamahatta” stands out with its wild percussion and Brazilian influences.
The album also features contributions from Brazilian musician Carlinhos Brown, recordings involving the Xavante people, and Jonathan Davis of Korn on “Lookaway”.
That mix gave “Roots” an identity of its own. It wasn’t simply another thrash album. Sepultura were bringing different rhythms and sounds into heavy music, and they weren’t afraid to experiment.
The Bad: Was This Still the Sepultura Fans Loved?
Here’s where the arguments begin.
Fans who loved the speed and technical thrash of “Beneath the Remains” and “Arise” didn’t necessarily want this new direction.
The riffs on “Roots” are often simpler, the groove is more important than speed, and some tracks stretch ideas for longer than they need to. At around 72 minutes, the album could have used a little trimming.
“Lookaway” is another dividing point. The guest appearances and alternative metal elements made it different, but not every old-school Sepultura fan wanted to hear that kind of experimentation.
And yes, the nu metal label keeps following this record, something Ross Robinson’s raw, percussive production only amplified. Some hear it as an important bridge between groove metal and the sound that exploded later in the decade. Others hear a band chasing a trend.
What Did Critics and Fans Think?
The reception was never completely one-sided.
AllMusic praised the album’s originality and its Brazilian influences, while also pointing out that its length and less impressive riff writing could lose some old-school thrash fans.
Not every review was kind. Entertainment Weekly criticised the album’s sound and vocals, while other listeners felt the experimentation didn’t always lead to strong songwriting.
Fan opinions are just as divided. Some listeners consider “Roots” their favourite Sepultura album and love its tribal percussion and heavy groove. Others prefer the earlier thrash records and feel the band lost something important along the way.
Even Max Cavalera has pushed back against calling it a nu metal record, describing its sound as something much more primitive and heavy.
The Verdict: PICK or PASS?
PICK.
“Roots” isn’t perfect. It runs too long, some ideas could have been developed better and it’s understandable why fans of the earlier albums struggled with the change.
But playing it safe would have been the easier option. Sepultura took risks, brought Brazilian influences into the centre of their sound and made an album that still gets people talking 30 years later.
You don’t have to love every track to recognise that “Roots” is a record with a strong identity.
And that is worth something.
Your Turn: PICK or PASS?
Was “Roots” a brave move that helped push metal forward, or do you prefer the faster, more aggressive Sepultura of the “Arise” era?
PICK – A classic that still hits hard.
PASS – Give me the old-school thrash Sepultura.
Tell us where you stand in the comments. No fence-sitting!



















